A group of public housing tenant and housing rights organizations have sued the Trump administration in Boston federal court to stop a new rule that could cause hundreds of immigrant families to lose housing or divide families.
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development issued a new rule on Nov. 12 that will prevent families whose members have different immigration statuses from getting prorated housing benefits. Advocates say the changes will force low-income immigrant families have to choose between splitting up or leaving their current housing.
“The new rule would force those families to either remove the ineligible individual or give up the subsidy,” said Joey Michalakes, deputy managing attorney of the housing unit at Greater Boston Legal Services, in an interview with GBH News.
“For many families, it’s not actually a choice, because the ineligible individual or individuals are parents, and the eligible members are U.S. citizen children who are minors. That is the circumstance of most affected families. So in effect, what that means is, these families have to leave the housing,” Michalakes said. Housing authorities will be mandated to implement the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development’s changes.
Plaintiffs in the lawsuit, filed Thursday, say the new rule violates both the Administrative Procedure Act and the Fifth Amendment’s due process clause, and that HUD violated its duty under the Fair Housing Act to eradicate discrimination.
Additionally, the lawsuit says the rule was put out in tandem with the Trump administration’s effort to “push the bounds” of the Supreme Court’s birthright citizenship ruling this summer.
This changes a 30-year-old practice of allowing families with mixed-immigration status to live together even if a member is undocumented or has a status not approved for federally subsidized housing. In those cases, the family member without the appropriate legal status would not receive the housing subsidy, so the other family members would pay more.
Three anonymous plaintiffs in the lawsuit are from mixed-status families. One of them lives in Massachusetts, has been in the U.S. since 2015, and is currently authorized to live and work in the state, but her immigration status isn’t among the categories with eligibility, according to the lawsuit. Three of her children are U.S. citizens (her eldest, age 12, is not). They all live together in an apartment with the assistance of federal subsidies.
Other plaintiffs include the Mass Union of Public Housing Tenants; Fall River Housing Authority Joint Tenants’ Council; Border Workers United; and Smith Houses Resident Association. The federal class action lawsuit was filed by the National Housing Law Project, The Legal Aid Society, LatinoJustice PRLDEF, Winston Taylor, Greater Boston Legal Services and Massachusetts Law Reform Institute.
The new rule would require all federal public housing recipients, including US citizens, to file what the plaintiffs claim is an “unreasonable” amount of extra paperwork, particularly for senior citizens.
“They’re going to ask to be chased down copies of birth certificates, of financial records. A lot of them are elderly, a lot of them are disabled,” said Dave Underhill, Mass Union’s Board Chair and a public housing tenant in Fall River. He’s a 19-year tenant of his complex, and the city has nearly 4,000 public housing residents.
“They don’t leave their buildings or their developments on a regular basis. That’s going to take a lot of work on behalf of the staff of the housing authority, which is going to take away from the day-to-day operations of what they have to do.” HUD didn’t include any funding mechanism for local housing authorities to hire more staff to implement the changes.
The Trump administration tried to advance a similar rule in its first term. This time, the proposed changes got more than 13,000 public comments nationwide, and was opposed by Massachusetts lawmakers and over a dozen local tenant organizations. It’s set to go into effect on Dec. 14.
After that, local housing authorities will issue notices requiring mixed-status families to verify eligibility of every person in a household within 90 days.
Green card holders, asylees, refugees, certain human trafficking victims, and immigrants with a few other statuses are eligible for federally subsidized housing. Immigrants who are undocumented or have temporary statuses or are in the process of attaining the previously mentioned statuses, are not.
The government estimates that 62,000 people could be displaced. The changes will require more complicated verification requirements for all tenants in federally subsidized housing — over 8.5 million people.
Michalakes said the lawsuit seeks to delay the effective date, and eventually prevent the rule change permanently after more thorough oral arguments are heard.
“What we do not want to see is families self-evicting on the basis of a proposal that has not meaningfully gone into effect yet,” he said.