This fall, Alpha School, an AI-powered private institution, opened its doors to Boston youth for the first time. The institution centers around their mission to have children love school and learning — without teachers. Instead, Alpha School Boston replaces traditional teachers with Guides who serve as motivational support as students complete academic coursework and workshops.
The schools vow to teach students through AI platforms in just two hours, twice as fast than traditional eight-hour school days. The other six hours are filled with workshops meant to teach students grit and hard work through civic duties and cognitive activities.
We’ve spoken with Erik Berg, the president of the Boston Teachers Union, who voiced his concerns about the Alpha School’s removal of the traditional student-teacher dynamics. Brian Burkhard, the lead research assessor for the institution’s Alpha Corps team, recently joined GBH’s All Things Considered host Arun Rath to give us an inside perspective on the institution. What follows lightly is a lightly edited transcript of their conversation:
Arun Rath: To help us understand this better, I’d like to just basically have you walk us through a day at Alpha. First, tell us about the human part — guides versus teachers. Tell us how is a guide different from a teacher and what kind of skills does a guide need to have as distinct from a teacher?
Brian Burkhard: Sure. That’s a great question. We talked about whether or not we should be called guides or teachers or coaches, and we did end up landing on guides. Traditional teachers, they are subject matter experts in the area they’re teaching. They also have to be able to teach that thing, which is not always the same thing, knowing something and teaching it. They have administrative tasks they have to handle, the grading, the lesson planning, they have to work with parents, and then they also have to motivate and know the kids.
So, our envisioning of what the guide does is taking those first four things off the table. And so the really important adults in our schools — our guides — they don’t need to be the people who are the subject matter experts in the academic content. They don’t have to be the ones grading assignments and giving feedback specifically on the academics. They don’t have to be the ones doing admin tasks, and they’re not the ones interfacing with parents constantly. They need to focus on just that one thing, which is, how do you motivate and support this child better than anyone else? That’s what their number-one goal is throughout the day.
During academics, if a child is struggling emotionally or with motivation, the guide will know, “what will motivate this person?” Or, “what is this person struggling with?” And they can step in and help with that. In the life skills workshops, they’re using their energy and their expertise to deliver these really fun lessons on different life skills we’ve chosen to target. As far as qualifications, that’s a great question. So all the guides have experience with children. There’s a pretty rigorous process for application. Part of that is what we call “Shadow Day.” And so guides, we’ll see them in action.
We’ll have them run a launch or be around for the day, and we’ll see how they interact with kids. And so I would say about half of our staff now are former traditional teachers, former educators who have heard about our model and were very excited to try this and wanted to focus on coaching kids, supporting kids, motivating kids, and not have to worry about the logistics and the lesson planning and the grading. And they could just be there to inspire and motivate. And so that’s what we look for — adults that can connect with children better than anybody else.
We’ve got really successful guides who used to be coaches, personal trainers, you know, experts at motivation. And who just have that great kid energy and are there for the kids and know them better than anybody else and help them find their purpose, help them stay motivated, and help them just love coming to school. Which, again, is our overarching concept — is kids should love coming to school, and the guide is just a huge, huge part of that.
Rath: I want to talk more about the life skills workshop, but first a bit more about how the learning works because it sounds like — I was reading about this — the guides — I keep wanting to say teachers — the guides are facilitating the emotional aspect of learning. Tell us a bit more about that thinking.
Burkhard: Sure. And I think it’s really helpful to point out here that the academics at Alpha are not taught by chatbots. We are anti-chatbot at Alpha. Chatbots, you know, you’re offloading your critical thinking. It’s cheating. So there are no chatbots during academics. Kids are not sitting there chatting with AI.
Rath: Tell us how it works. Like, you have to put us in the student’s shoes. How are they going about that in their day?
Burkhard: Well, I guess the important question here is we wanted kids to love coming to school. And so if you ask kids, “what would make you love school more?” it’s less school or no school. And so the design question was, well, how can we then make the academics more efficient or compress the academics? And so that kids have more time to socialize and do really fun workshops together. And so the answer to that we’ve known for decades. And so if you’re familiar with the education research, Project Follow Through [by] Benjamin Bloom.
It’s direct instruction, it’s mastery pacing, it’s immediate feedback. These are things that software can facilitate very well. It’s a very personalized academics platform. It’s called TimeBack because again, you’re giving the kids the rest of their time back for the day. It’s not a bot, it’s not an AI chatbot. It’s very similar to other educational platforms folks are probably familiar with. They’ll get some instruction, they’ll do some worked examples, they’ll get immediate feedback. The bonus is that the platform knows where the student is at across all their subjects. And so whereas other ed-tech might be fragmented or unstructured, the TimeBack platform knows where you’re at in all your subjects.
So you could be in fourth grade reading and seventh grade science and sixth grade math, and it will find the exact areas that you need to practice. And so it’s just very efficient and effective way for people to learn — direct instruction, immediate feedback. And so the kids actually have a lot of agency in the way they learn academics.
So if you think I really don’t want to start my day off with math today. I’m going to do my reading first. You can do that. If you want to sit by a window or you want to find somewhere quiet, you know, you can do that too. And so kids actually have a lot of control over their learning journey, and the material they’re presented is exactly what they need to see to continue learning in each of the core academic subjects. And so that’s sort of what it looks like for the kids for the first two hours of their day.
Rath: And on the academic side, how does grading work in Alpha or tracking the mastery of skills? How does that work?
Burkhard: Yeah, so no report cards. It’s, “do they know the content?” Not only are they knowledgeable, are they fluent? We’re making sure we can fill the kids’ heads with all the important facts they need for reading, science, social studies, math, whatever it is. We have knowledge graphs and knowledge trees in the platform and the kids will work through the material. And it will find the exact thing. So maybe I’m at 75% of the fifth-grade curriculum and I’m really bad at exponents and you really need some help on your distributive property, say.
It would give us extra reps and extra practice until we’ve mastered the material we need to move on to the next bit of knowledge. And so sometimes we say you would never build the first floor of your house if your foundation was only, you know, 80% complete or 90% complete. You want really strong mastery and fluency. The platform can be adaptive in putting the exact material kids have to practice in front of them before they move on. As you’ve probably read, they do the MAP scores, a test of academic progress, to benchmark against where they should be for their age and their grade. We make sure they’re learning all the right material at pace.
Rath: With it being able to be so individualized to that degree, how much interaction is there among students in the class, or is it really just guide and teacher one-on-one?
Burkhard: Yeah, so the majority of the day, they’re with other students. The academic portion is hyper-personalized. And so, for when they’re on the TimeBack platform, the student will be working on their own academic material that they need to focus on. The other students will be in the classroom doing their own work. The guides will be there as well. If a student’s having some problems focusing or being motivated, the guides can pull them aside one-on-one and work with them as well. So, they’re all physically in the same place, but they’re working on their own material to move forward. But the majority of the day, the students are socializing, their recess, their playtime, their breaks, their workshops, their town hall. And so most of the day is spent with other students and with the Guides working on the life skills aspect of the curriculum.
Rath: And you said these are — they’re not bots that are teaching. These are not bots that are working with the kids. They’re working with software. Where does AI come into all of this?
Burkhard: Sure, that’s a great question. And so it’s really on the back end. And so just the LLMs [Large Language Models] have gotten to a point now where we could facilitate this hyper-personalization. And so where there are other learning platforms I’m sure folks have used with their children — and I use with mine as well — you can see how it can work through the material. But having one integrated platform that can understand where you’re at in all the different subjects down to this micro level of, you know, the specifics of the of the gerunds or the exponents is really where AI comes in. So it’s on the back end.
And so being able to put the right material in front of the child personalizes the curriculum that they see and what they practice. They are not chatting with a chatbot. There’s no window where they’re talking with a robot. I think that’s a big misconception. The AI is really on the backend for the academics. And it’s just the technology has reached a point where we can optimize exactly what the kids are working on. And so it’s — you can think of it sort of like a very personalized adaptive workbook that puts the exact material in front of the kids.
And so, whereas in a traditional classroom, a teacher might have to teach more towards the median, and you might be a bit despondent if the material’s over you, or a bit bored if the material’s too easy for you, the kids are getting just what they need to stay engaged and motivated. And because it’s compressed and it’s just the beginning of their day, they know that they get to spend the rest of the day doing really fun stuff that they love. And hence, our focus on the love of school, in which both the life skills workshops are paramount, but also these really strong connections with their guides, who, again, our goal is to make them the favorite adult person in their life outside their family who they go to and who understands them better than anybody else.
Rath: And I did say we were going to talk more about the workshop part of things because this only gets us to lunchtime. So tell us about after lunch, what workshop time is about.
Burkhard: So actually the day begins with a little bit of workshop time. It’s called Limitless Launch, and so this is about 15 minutes, every single campus does this, every grade. You can think of it sort of as a combination of Tony Robbins motivation and some Carol Dweck growth mindset. And so this is 15 minutes just to get kids moving. They might look like icebreaker activities to adults. Maybe they’re doing a Teamwork Tuesday trying to cross a river. Maybe they’re doing a Mindfulness Monday or a Thankfulness Thursday.
And so the first 50 minutes are just sort of going to be this engaging time for moving and motivating and reflecting. So that’s the beginning of the day. They’ll move into their two hours of core academics. And again, it’s Pomodoro method. So they’ll take five-minute breaks, 15-minute breaks. So it’s not two hours straight. But then to your point, yes, lunch happens. And I will point out that lunch, there are no screens. No screens are allowed at lunch, at breaks, at recess. We are bell to bell, no cell phones also at Alpha School. And so once academics has ended and lunch begins, screens are down, and then after lunch the workshops begin.
And so each student will be working on about three workshops per session. So we have five sessions throughout the school year, and each workshop focuses on a different life skill. And so in session one, the life skills we focused on were independence and feedback and upholding community standards. And so each workshop lasts about an hour or so, And so kids will rotate throughout the week.
So maybe they’ll do the same one on Monday, Tuesday, and a different one Wednesday, Friday. And they also will spend time at town hall. But in the workshop, they’re gonna be focusing on ... the very specific life skill, which is the goal for that time period. And so I’m here in Boston. And so you can think about our feedback workshops from session one to give you some examples. The younger kids were working with the Eric Carle Museum. And so if you’re familiar with “Hungry Caterpillar,” they were working and iterating on some artwork. And so their goal was to use feedback to make their drawing and their art look more like an Eric Carle drawing.
And there’s actually a framework for what that is, and we learned from the museum there’s sort of these five components. And so the kids would iterate on their feedback. And so they were practicing getting feedback, working towards a goal in a really fun medium and a story they knew, and making these animals. And then our feedback workshop for older kids, you think about middle school, they were designing robots that could go into the Charles River and dredge up trash and collect trash. And so for the older kids, feedback looked like going to MIT and talking to robotics experts and learning how they could improve their designs.
And so the higher end of feedback would be, well, how do I get specific feedback about things that need to improve? How do I prioritize the feedback when I do get it? And so that’s sort of how the spectrum looks for that life skill. And that was what we were doing here in session one in Boston. Independence workshops this session were all around wilderness survival, which I had a great time helping to teach some of those workshops. And I was the chaperone for the overnight camping trip for our kids. And so that’s what they’re spending most of the day on, is learning how to use these really important life skills workshops in engaging, motivating, exciting, and as much as we can, localized contexts.